Sunday 30 December 2012

Reactions to Rape, Part II


The unfortunate victim of this incident has been christened with such names as Amanat, Damini, Nirbhaya and so on. All over India, people are mourning the death of “India’s daughter”. People are lighting candles on the streets. Grief has spread to all corners of the country. This is what I don’t understand. Whilst I do not condone the actions of the six accused in any way whatsoever, I believe that India as a nation is blessed with a serious problem – a problem that links directly to its middle class, its spine.

Quote (section taken from Times Of India’s website)
Honour Nirbhaya by making this pledge
- We will personally treat all women at home and elsewhere with respect and demand the same from others
- We will not practice discrimination against women at home and in the workplace and will fight it wherever we see it
- We will intervene in whatever way we can when we see a woman being harassed whether verbally or by deeds. In all such cases, we will insist on FIRs being lodged and acted upon
- We will not vote for politicians who treat women with disrespect

There’s a fundamental problem with the mindset here. I do not intend to dwell on the rather optimistic pledge outlined above. Instead I would like to take this opportunity to quote a simple statistic. In Delhi this year, there were 635 rape cases. And one conviction. One. ONE. More than zero, less than two. If we didn’t waste all our damned money on buying candles for one victim and organising mass protests demanding that Manmohan Singh find a new job then maybe we’d be able to think of the other 634. I mean no disrespect to her memory but it certainly looks like India doesn’t care about the memories of all those that suffer in silence.

This brings us on to what aggravates me so much. Why does a girl have to be raped, beaten, thrown off a bus and unsuccessfully hospitalised for two weeks in order to raise awareness about an issue that has plagued India since god knows when? What can be more hypocritical than that? Do we wait until a family member suffers pancreatic cancer before demanding access to healthcare? As a cricket mad nation, do we ever pass up the most miniscule of opportunities to dig into the team and its players? No. And no. Then why we wait so long to finally react to this is beyond me.

Speaking of reacting brings me on to the next big problem. How we react. It is unfortunate that blinded by rage over recent events, the public is basically picking up every statement made by figures of authority and twisting them into anti-feminist, anti-change statements. Obviously in some cases this hasn’t actually been necessary – cue Botsa Satyanarayana’s “That particular woman (the Delhi rape victim) should have applied her mind before boarding the private bus. Anyway, it was a small incident” statement. However, twisting Manmohan Singh’s “theek hai” (it’s ok) remark to a cameraman into an anti-feminist statement is nothing short of pathetic. It just highlights the dismal urge everyone seems to have to find a scapegoat.

Like Lassie before me, I’m not trying to play down the issue. I also think that change will come eventually. All I believe is that reacting and retaliating like hooligans makes us as human as those six men.

- Chap

Saturday 29 December 2012

Reactions to Rape, Facebook Style


This is dedicated to Damini, Nirbhaya, Amanat. Not just the unfortunate but brave Daughter who passed away this morning, but all the Daughters who have passed away because they fell victim to heinous crimes. 

13 days ago a 23 year old girl was raped by six men on a moving bus, beaten with a rusty rod and thrown out. She passed away this morning, after being shifted to Singapore for medical treatment (the political reasons for that, I am not interested in).

For once, I am stepping away from taunting politicians and policemen and the establishment in general. Today, I want to talk about the phenomenon I like to call “social (networking) activism”. Succinctly put- sorry activists, no revolutionary work to be done here. Changing our cover photos and display pictures to inspirational quotes about women equality and the injustice of rape doesn’t “spread awareness” about anything, it just makes distinguishing profiles from thumbnails alone impossible. I recognize that there is nothing we enjoy more than rallying around a common cause from behind our laptops but honestly, there’s nothing to do here other than develop a sort of sensitivity regarding degrading comments that isn’t going to come with updating your profile picture and raking in the likes.

Men reading this- I dare you; the next time you see a girl in a dress or a skirt, think of her as a person with a family and a brother and a mother and father and dreams and a life of her own, and not as ‘maal’ (an object). Every single male out there who has changed his Facebook status or tweeted about India being in the dumps- I ask you- when was the last time you made a joke about women in kitchen? Munni and Sheila are relatively safe because they dance on screen- what about those who don’t? I dare you to ask yourself whether they ask to be raped. This is the first time in a long time we’ve come across such a horrifying case of rape, but honestly this isn’t the only time. In no way do I intend to belittle what just happened- this article is dedicated to Braveheart- I just want to know where everyone’s conscience is when so many girls in our country are being raped as I type this and as you read this. I confess, I am referring to the Guwahati molestation case when I say that just because some of the more sensational cases catch the media’s attention doesn’t mean the others are less important. Just as quickly, however, they are forgotten. Quick FYI- the lead rapist in that case got 2 years in prison and an overwhelming fine of Rs. 2000!! Justice system at work, ladies and gentlemen!

Another piece of advice men- next time you go out on the streets, don’t go out alone lest you lose control! Take a woman with you to keep you safe. Hey, that isn’t very fair of me- terming all men as rapists who need watching over. Well, maybe it’s time to stop terming all women as rape victims who need the same.

Social network activism means very little and achieves even less if everyone gets caught up in a frenzy over everything. Remember Kony? Remember that one time everyone changed their display pictures to cartoons to spread awareness of child abuse? Let’s face it- everyone wants to do something because everyone else is doing it. If I sound cynical because I’m slamming down attempts to take a stand, make a change, it’s probably because I am. I know there’s little scope for organizing rallies and protests in the country I reside in, but your time might be better spent developing respect for women when it really counts rather than making statuses and logging in every 10 minutes to see who ‘liked’ it. India has risen up in solidarity in a way we rarely see and change is arguably around the corner. Personally I believe that laws will be passed but on the grassroots change, if any, will be slow to take place, but this article is not about that. I am not denying that social networking activism gets nowhere- nobody can deny Occupy Wall Street or the Arab Spring. I am simply pointing out that updating your status pleading to fellow men about something that you yourself need to be reminded about is pathetic, at best. There are men and women out on the streets of India, silent in solidarity. I am not saying you shouldn’t do nothing- I am saying do something that wont result in nothing. And if you’re going to do something that you wont remember to do in a month or two, don’t bother doing it.

This is a plea.

-Lassie

Chap and I are collaborating, for the first time, to present to you something we both feel very strongly about. His article will come very soon. 

Source: 
http://www.hindustantimes.com/India-news/Guwahati/Guwahati-molestation-case-Amarjyoti-Kalita-convicted-journalist-walks-free/Article1-969757.aspx